Has the Internet Solved the Problem with Music? Did Indie Music Legend Steve Albini Kill the Sharing=Theft Argument Once and For All?

On Saturday November 15th, 2014, legendary recording engineer (Nirvana's In Utero) and independent music business icon Steve Albini gave what should be a widely-discussed keynote address at Melbourne Australia's annual Face the Music conference.

The provocative point that Mr. Albini was making? 

The future of music may not be as grim as some have been saying...

Mr. Albini's argument?

The music business might actually be getting better. Yes, the internet is squeezing out the middlemen - whose lamentations are many (see below) - but there are noteworthy positives as well.

In light of the awful things some internet-skeptics - like Prof. Jon Taplin of USC and author Robert Levine - have been saying about the music business and the internet, Steve Albini's talk will likely cause some consternation.

But I welcome Mr. Albini's voice - as I've been struggling to make a similar argument for some time (you can check out representative prior posts challenging Prof. Taplin's hyperbolic assertion that "the music died in 2001" and Mr. Levine's equally ridiculous assertion that the internet is "simply too chaotic to provide the infrastructure for a 21st-century economy" to see how I've tried to say what Steve Albini said more expertly and authoritatively in Melbourne last weekend).

If you're a music fan or care at all about how 21st culture is evolving, I strongly urge you to read the full transcript of what Steve Albini said at Face the Music (The Guardian has kindly provided a full transcript, accessible via this link.)

For the purposes of this post, I'll include just one excerpt from Steve Albini's very entertaining Nov. 15th, 2014 talk here - an excerpt that seems especially noteworthy to me in light of my ongoing feud with fear mongerers like Prof. Jon Taplin and Robert Levine.

Here's what Steve Albini said about the evolving fan relationship to music in the age of the internet: 

"There’s a lot of shade thrown by people in the music industry about how terrible the free sharing of music is, how it’s the equivalent of theft, etc. That’s all bullshit and we’ll deal with that in a minute. But for a minute I want you to look at the experience of music from a fan’s perspective, post-internet. Music that is hard to find was now easy to find... Long-forgotten music has been given a second life. And bands whose music that was ahead of its time has been allowed to reach a niche audience that the old mass distribution failed to find for them, as one enthusiast turns on the next and this forgotten music finally gets it due."


If that doesn't grab your attention (e.g., if you're not curious about how Steve Albini goes on to address the sharing = theft argument), you probably should check to see if you have a pulse.

I am so grateful to The Guardian for reporting on Steve Albini's talk.

And I'm grateful for the internet, which is making circulation of Mr. Albini's ideas possible.

(I'm not sure whether any account of what Steve Albini said has shown up in major outlets in the US yet - many also have an interest in the old ways of content distribution.)

From my perspective, Christmas came early this year. 

The only other thing I'd like under my tree?

I'm also hoping a video will show up of Steve Albini's full talk on Face the Music's YouTube channel.

Why Tepid Hollywood Comedy "Bride Wars" is Being Remade in China

Mid-level Western films that might appeal to marriage-minded young Chinese women - if re-imagined starring Chinese actresses struggling with culturally relevant stumbling blocks - might be ripe for remake.

Or at least that seems to be the thinking behind China's Bona Film Group's remake of director Gary Winick's 2009 Fox comedy Bride Wars.

Although the original Bride Wars didn't set the world on fire - grossing under US$60M in English-speaking North America, and even less in foreign theaters, and earning a dismal 10% on review aggregator rottentomatoes.com - the booming Chinese theatrical market needs serviceable scripts targeted at a young female demographic.

So, over the summer of 2014, director Tony Chan shot a Bride Wars remake in Shanghai, starring Chinese pop idols Angelababy and Ni Ni in the roles first played by Kate Hudson and Anne Hathaway.

Why remake a Hollywood also-ran?

Even though there are millions more young men than women in China today, the theatrical motion picture business in China has seen Chinese films that cater to young women (like 2013's So Young) stand up at the box office against the toughest of Hollywood competition (e.g., Iron Man 3).

Why are modestly budgeted local films about young women overcoming rather prosaic problems (prosaic at least by Tony-Stark-encounters-an-enemy-whose-reach-knows-no-bounds standards) working so well in China right now?

Young men and women are moving to urban centers in China by the tens of millions each year. The traditional ways of making a living, falling in love and settling down have been disrupted. And, in every city, shopping malls - with glittering new multiplexes - are going up. The crowds that fill these malls and theaters include many young female workers - newly independent 20 somethings eager for comedies about young women struggling to make a better life.

It was inevitable that Hollywood would take notice.  

Buckets of money earned by fish-out-of-water and rom-com genres? 

Genres that veteran Hollywood execs and screenwriters know how to develop? 

Genres that have been passed-over lately by the studios in favor of superhero tentpoles?

Yes please.

While mid-budget fare has been dying in tinseltown, the Bride Wars remake in China may provide a glimmer of hope to Western romantic fantasy feature film writers who've recently been jilted (left at the altar?).


Let's see how Bride Wars fares at the box office in China in 2015.

Perhaps genres requiring a relatively small investment that nobody wants right now in Hollywood can prosper in China?

Which genres will prove the most profitable in China in the coming years? 

Will US style rom-coms remain a part of the mix in China?


The producer of the Chinese version of Bride Wars is Bona Film Group. 

Perhaps a look at Bona's recent releases might be helpful for predicting the future of the Chinese theatrical film business?

Bona Films has had a very good year - taking 3 of the top 14 spots in China's summer (May through August) 2014 box office derby with The Continent (fourth in China's overall summer box office) followed by The White Haired Witch and Overheard 3

Bona also had a very strong third quarter in 2014 in China, holding over The Continent and The White-Haired Witch and premiering imports Non-Stop (US$16M box office gross in China) and Pompeii (also around US$16M box office gross in China).

As COO Jeffrey Chan observed in Bona's Nov. 13th, 2014 conference call with investors and analysts: "The Continent was the company’s summer box office leader at RMB628 million (US$102M), followed by The White-Haired Witch with RMB319 million (US$52M). These two films were key revenue drivers in the third quarter and their performances were in line with our expectations, in terms of their wide audience appeal and result of our aggressive promotional effort."

But the competition in China's film business is clearly heating up.

Jack Ma of Alibaba (which coincidentally reported US$9B of retail sales on Tuesday Nov. Nov. 11th, 2014 - the shopping event known as 光棍节 or Guānggùn Jié or "Single's Day" in China) is sitting on an enormous pile of cash following his record-making IPO.

The speculation about whether Alibaba intends to use some of the US$25B raised on Wall Street to buy a Hollywood studio - or a library of Western content - and how that might impact the competitive landscape for motion pictures in China - was on the minds of analysts participating in the Bona conference call.

Mention was also made on the Nov. 13th, 2014 Bona call of the Wanda Group's dominant position in theaters. As of Nov. 2014, Bona owns and operates just 22 movie theaters with 182 screens in the mainland. At the start of 2014, Bona's competitor, Wanda Cinema (also a producer of films), owned seven times as many theaters in China - as well as a controlling interest in the second biggest movie theater chain in the US. And Wanda was not letting up - contracting with Imax to build another 200 giant-format theaters in China by 2021.

What else was discussed?

The following are excerpts from a transcript of Bona Film Group's Third Quarter 2014 Earnings Conference Call held November 13, 2014 8:00 PM ET.

Yu Dong – Founder, Chairman and CEO of Bona Film Group (BONA)

"Total box office in domestic China reached RMB21.9 billion (US$3.57B) in the first nine months of this year  [2014] which is greater than the full year box office of 2013..."

"The total China box office is expected to grow nearly RMB8 billion (US$1.31B) more than last year reaching close to RMB30 billion (US$4.89B - which is less than one-half of the box office of US$10.9B reported in English speaking North America in 2013, but US box office seems to be in decline, while China's box office has been growing at around 30% each year)."

"Going forward Bona is going to focus on two key areas, local films and Hollywood films... [In addition to local films] Bona is planning to invest in and produce some Hollywood mainstream film and attract excellent production talents."

Jeffrey Chan – Bona's COO

"The first of the five production projects between Bona and Fox International, Bride Wars is scheduled to be release [sic] in 2015. This young romance comedy is directed by Tony Chan and stars China most popular young actresses Angelababy and Ni Ni. The film adapts the proven story structure and is set after the successful 2009 Fox Comedy of the same title and is tailored to the taste of today’s young domestic Chinese audience. We believe that this new film will ride on the growing popularity of the genre in China to become a big crowd pleaser."

The Bona earnings call transcription that I've quoted here comes courtesy of Seeking Alpha.

Note: I've also written about Bona before. If you want some background, my Sept, 13th, 2013 post on this blog might be a good place to start.

Randy Finch's Film Blog:

Thoughts from a film producer about making and distributing films.